After perusing the menu I decided on an IPA battle Royale. It was going to be west coast Vs Midwest. Pacific Ocean Vs. Rocky Mountains. Ballast Point's Big Eye IPA Vs. Avery's DuganA.
First off I'm not exactly sure how to pronounce DuganA. is it Duggen..Ay, DuggenAy or is it, as the server prounced it, DooGahnAh? I think I prefer Duggen..Ay especially since the semi snooty server guy tried to correct me. So, Duggen..Ay it is, and it doesn't really matter HOW you pronounce it because you could call it dirt and it would still taste really really good.
|Big Eye IPA on the Left DuganA on the right|
On the nose there was a LOT of barnyard, feet, armpit, Brett smelling. There was more barnyard in this one than other IPA's I've had, like Wild Devil, that were purposefully inoculated with Brettanomyces. It gave it a depth that I really liked. Musky with some pine of course.
Taste was more barnyard, followed by barnyard dirt, musky, pine. I really enjoyed this beer as there were many layers to peel back. My only complaint was there was a little too much carbonation
The Big Eye also poured a bit darker of a copper color though the lacing was much tighter.
Light and sweet on the nose with some lemon and obligatory pine.
Taste was lemony pine which followed the nose to the T. Not much bubble. All in all a solid IPA.
The win definitely goes to Avery though.